revmary

The Synod PJC Said What . . .?

The occasion for beginning this blog was the completion of the Appeal Hearing before the General Assembly Permanent Judicial Commission (GAPJC) in the matter of Parnell et al v. San Francisco Presbytery. The GAPJC rendered its Decision and Order on August 2, 2011, and the response of the Complainants’ legal team followed. By way of review, what the GAPJC did was to dismiss all allegations of error that applied the previously encoded standard for church officers, the requirement “to live either in fidelity within the covenant of marriage between a man and a woman, or chastity in singleness” (the former […]

The Synod PJC Said What . . .? Read More »

On the Other Hand: Reasons for Leaving the PCUSA

Considering the missional implications of Staying or Leaving the PCUSA, outlined this week have been some reasons why Staying can be seen as missional. More will be said on that topic in the days to come. But today, to keep some balance in the discussion, let us consider the merits of Leaving. The following ideas have been mentioned or implied in some of the social network traffic this week: 1.  The PCUSA itself has left the true church.  If the church through its councils and judicial commissions has departed from the beliefs that originally defined it, then the church has

On the Other Hand: Reasons for Leaving the PCUSA Read More »

Is It Possible to Be Kingdom Focused While Remaining in the PCUSA?

I commend to my readers the comments that appeared in response to yesterday’s post. They represent both sides of the Stay or Leave the PCUSA debate and are really quite helpful for understanding and empathizing with both liberal and conservative points of view. If that reading exercise does not totally exhaust you, then I offer just a short thought for today. Yesterday I spilled the beans about my intent to stay with the PCUSA for now, and I am going to continue to explore why this track has merit in the days to come. My purpose for doing so is

Is It Possible to Be Kingdom Focused While Remaining in the PCUSA? Read More »

Stay or Leave: Strangers in a Strange Land

Over the last two weeks, I have been trying to unpack the very difficult situation evangelicals experience as conservatives within a liberal Protestant denomination, the PCUSA. My intent has not been to whine nor to accuse, but to sort out the dilemmas individuals face when they realize they do not belong in a church they feel has left them. Facebook and this blog (among many others) have given people a platform in which to express their feelings and thoughts on the matter. In those forums, it seems the available options are laid out in rather black and white terms: if

Stay or Leave: Strangers in a Strange Land Read More »

To Leave or Not to Leave: That Is the Question

The “organized church” of the twenty-first century is a far cry from the fledgling association evident a few decades after Christ’s Ascension. The Christian Church has seen the East/West split between Catholic and Orthodox in 1054, the Protestant Reformation of the 16th century, and the continued delineation of Christian tribes by theological emphasis since then. Does the existence of these denominations indicate that the Church of Jesus Christ has failed or that it exists in a perpetual less-than-God-glorifying state? This is an important point to ponder. If the answer is “Yes,” then any consideration of breaking from the PCUSA—with the

To Leave or Not to Leave: That Is the Question Read More »

The Political Incorrectness of Church Discipline

For the last two days I have been sitting on this next post, trying to decide which topic should come first: the legitimacy of Christian denominations or what one might do when/if one’s own denomination detaches from its roots. I am not procrastinating on these questions, but think we need to do a little more work from within Paul’s letters to gain some guidance: The apostle Paul did not live in an environment of denominations as we know them; the church, from his point of view, was still unified in a loose association and he was one of its most

The Political Incorrectness of Church Discipline Read More »

Paul’s Priority of Sound Doctrine

The apostle Paul dramatically encountered the Risen Christ on his way to round up “illegal” Christians in Damascus. A zealous Pharisee and a Roman citizen from Tarsus, this convert understood the Law and claimed to have lived it to the letter. His world was rocked, however, when Jesus himself confronted Paul with the question, “Why are you persecuting Me?” Just as Jesus had addressed Peter personally with a Key Question, now in Acts 9 Jesus personally addresses this one misguided and angry enforcer with the grace and truth of the gospel. A career change was in Paul’s future, and it

Paul’s Priority of Sound Doctrine Read More »

What Jesus Considered the Essential Tenet

In light of the interesting comments and conversation resulting from yesterday’s post, I have elected to spend one more day on Jesus before moving on to Paul, regarding doctrinal expectations. The gospels give us no evidence that Jesus was insistent upon a particular “system” of doctrine. The Pharisees had a very punctilious system of doctrine, but there was something seriously wrong with them spiritually, and Jesus called them out about it all the time. Things could be distilled into a far less complicated framework of belief. For Jesus, there were two main core beliefs around which everything else would fall

What Jesus Considered the Essential Tenet Read More »

The Quest for Doctrinal Purity

In the current climate of the PCUSA, sadly, some conservative church members approach their pastors with the news that they are leaving for someplace where they can feel more at home theologically. They may not put it in quite those words, but they express dismay over the church’s apparent departure from biblical norms (referring to the outcomes of adoption of Amendment 10-A, the new Form of Government, and the August judicial commission ruling confirming changes in ordination standards). Their resolution of the personal, internal dissonance these actions cause is to search for a church home that is untainted by questionable

The Quest for Doctrinal Purity Read More »

The Seeds of “Church” that Jesus Planted

The PCUSA, and particularly the evangelical wing of the church, is pondering the meaning of its existence and its future. Though I am certainly not the first to raise questions designed to get us back to our roots, it is timely to ask what Jesus had in mind, if anything, for a church, the Church, or his followers as a group. To that end, I have compiled a list of Scriptures relevant to such an inquiry and welcome your input if you think I have forgotten something. For simplicity, the terms “believers” and “Christians” refer to individuals who have trusted

The Seeds of “Church” that Jesus Planted Read More »

Scroll to Top